Indy may be educated more than Mclain, but Mclain is much better at thinking fast in life threatning situations. Yea indy may have a whip, but you really think Mclain will let him get close enough to use it? Fuck, indy would be like cheddar cheese with all bullet holes in him. And even if indy got the ship around Johns arm, Mclain would just pull the whip and indy towards him and clothesline Indy. And the main reason Indy would lose is because he wouldnt kill Mclain if he had the chance, even if he could he’d still lose
remember when indy could blow the arc up? (he didnt know he was going to win in the end) He pussyied out and let the nazi’s take that victory, whereas John Mclain would have blow the arc up, it may be reckless, but it gets the job done 
]]>if he was around when ww2 was going on he wouldnt get Hitler’s signature, he’d kick his ass!
the only way Indy would win is if he threw sand in John’s eyes and bit him (like with the nazi in RotLA)
sure Indy has a whip but how fair is that in a fist fight?
at the end of that fight you’d definately hear YIPPEE KI YAY! ]]>
indy fought out of nazi germany TWICE. maclane only fought pseudo nazis.
maclane can jump as many cars into helicopters as he wants, indy killed a guy who could rip your heart right out of your breathing chest.
maclane needed samuel l. jackson to defeat his enemy, indy only needed a little asian kid.
on top of a building, in a desert, in an airport hangar, on a ship, indiana would whoop maclanes ass and send him back to his tired ass ex-wife while indiana would meet a hot chick.
]]>John beats up a hot, frail looking girl (though we all agree that she ain’t that frail) and makes jokes right after it. I don’t think he comes anywhere near the “pussy” category on that one (given the fact that guys here respect women and most of us wouldn’t have the balls to hit one I guess)
Indy, he would probably get smacked around by the same chick. For the same reason we would get smacked around.
Indy Vs John in a mano a mano fight ? No gun, no whip ? Like he said, McClane’s that fucking energizer bunny ! Ain’t no possibility he loses ^^
]]>Indiana Jones
College Professer
Thinks on his feet
Often fights by the seat of his pants
Has often used “Creative weaponry” in a pinch ( Rock, Chair, Table Leg, Etc. )
has had several brushes with death, most of which were supernatural.
Carries 6 shot revolver, a whip, Fedora, Leather Coat and his ever trusty satchel.
John Mclane
Bad Ass New York Cop
Thinks on his feet
Also fights by the seat of his pants and has used creative weaponry. ( Car pwns Helicopter )
Has had several brushes with death, most involving bombs, guns, and a ventilation shaft.
Carries a 9mm Pistol, a badge, muscle T, and an attitude.
Indiana Jones V.S. McClane would have to come down to where, with what, and how long.
No guns mono y mono, large empty room: Indy, He’s taken on guys TWICE his size before and has been known to use alot of unconventional tactics with his whip and his fists. He’d have whip grappled John’s leg and had him on the floor, slung it around John’s arm and heaved him into a wall. It’s not powerful… but it’s useful.
Guns, Empty Bar. McClane, with his 9mm, his ridiculously infinite clip, and his military-esque shooting. Indy can only last for so long before McClane’s skill finally pays off.
And Finally a Straight up Bar Fight, no guns. Indy. We’ve seen what happens when Indy Takes on SEVERAL Guys at once in a bar.
That’s all I have to say on the subject.
Correct me if I’m wrong… but I just think Doc. Jones just has what it takes.
John McClane: Just a fly in the ointment, Hans. The monkey in the wrench. The pain in the ass. ]]>